What’s the Real Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint?

If you’re weighing the cost of wallpaper vs paint, you’re not alone. Many Winnipeg homeowners assume paint is the budget choice — but that’s not always true. Wallpaper can offer better durability, bolder style, and fewer touch-ups over time.

Let’s break down the real numbers and reveal which option will give your walls the biggest return on investment.

1. Upfront Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint: The Obvious Winner?

When comparing the cost of wallpaper vs paint, paint usually wins — at first glance. A can of interior paint costs less per square foot than most wallpaper rolls. But that’s just one piece of the puzzle.

  • Paint: $2–$6 per sq ft (including labour)
  • Wallpaper: $3–$7 per sq ft, plus removal fees if replacing old paper

Still, wallpaper can cover wall flaws and last three times longer. That reduces your total investment over the years — which matters if you’re in your “forever home.”

2. Labour Costs: The Hidden Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint

The next factor to consider in the cost of wallpaper vs paint is installation. Painting a room is generally faster and cheaper to complete. Wallpaper takes longer, especially when matching seams or applying adhesive.

If you’re hiring pros (and we recommend you do), expect:

  • Paint application: 1–2 days for a typical room
  • Wallpaper hanging: 2–3 days depending on complexity and prep

And don’t forget: if you already have old wallpaper, you’ll need to factor in removal. That can add $1–$4 per sq ft.

cost of wallpaper vs paint​

3. Longevity and Durability: Long-Term Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint

This is where wallpaper starts pulling ahead. While the cost of wallpaper vs paint may seem higher upfront, wallpaper lasts much longer — often 12 to 15 years with minimal upkeep. Paint? Closer to 3 to 5 years, especially in busy homes.

That means fewer repaints, less labour, and more time enjoying your space instead of scheduling touch-ups.

In the end, the cost of wallpaper vs paint becomes a question of short-term savings versus long-term value.

4. Design Flexibility: Style Can Influence the Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint

If you want to change colours frequently, paint gives you more flexibility at a lower cost. But if you’re designing a luxury space or a commercial property, wallpaper’s texture and depth might be worth the added expense.

You may end up spending more on accent walls, trim, or specialty finishes with paint — which affects the final cost of wallpaper vs paint in a way many don’t anticipate.

5. Maintenance Over Time: Don’t Ignore This Cost Factor

Here’s another overlooked piece of the puzzle: maintenance.

  • Paint chips and scuffs easily, especially in hallways and kid-friendly homes.
  • Modern wallpaper is washable, scuff-resistant, and often hides imperfections.

So the cost of wallpaper vs paint shifts again — paint may need touch-ups or a full repaint every few years. Wallpaper? Set it and forget it (as long as it’s installed properly).

cost of wallpaper vs paint​

6. Room-by-Room Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint

Not every room needs wallpaper — and not every room should be painted.

  • Best rooms for paint: kitchens, bathrooms, utility spaces
  • Best rooms for wallpaper: dining rooms, bedrooms, feature walls, offices

That means the smartest approach might be a mix of both. But knowing where each shines will help you weigh the cost of wallpaper vs paint per room.

7. Wallpaper Removal: The Underrated Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint

One of the biggest “gotchas” is removing old wallpaper. Depending on how it was installed (and how long it’s been there), it can take hours — or days.

You’ll need to factor in labour and disposal fees. So even though new wallpaper is trending, if you’re replacing old wallpaper, the cost of wallpaper vs paint can temporarily spike.

Need help stripping wallpaper without damaging your walls? Contact our team.

8. Resale Value: Will the Cost of Wallpaper vs Paint Pay Off?

Paint tends to be the safer bet if you’re preparing to sell your home. Neutral paint colours appeal to buyers and make spaces feel clean, modern, and move-in ready.

Wallpaper, while stylish, is more personal — and may require removal if buyers don’t share your taste.

That’s why realtors often ask about the cost of wallpaper vs paint during home staging projects.

cost of wallpaper vs paint​

The Verdict: Paint vs Wallpaper — Which One Wins in Winnipeg?

Let’s recap the cost of wallpaper vs paint in plain terms:

Feature Paint Wallpaper
Upfront Cost Cheaper Higher upfront
Installation Time Faster Slower
Durability 3–5 years lifespan 12–15 years lifespan
Maintenance Touch-ups needed Low maintenance
Removal Easy to paint over Can be messy
Resale Value Safer bet Depends on taste

Ready to Paint with Integrity?

Whether you're planning a full strata repaint, refreshing your living room walls, or upgrading your commercial space — we’re here to make your project stress-free and beautifully done. With over 30 years of experience in Winnipeg, our team is trusted by hundreds of homeowners and property managers across the city.

We paint with purpose, precision, and pride.
Visit our homepage or get started by exploring our:

Residential Painting Services

Commercial Painting Services

Contact Us

Prefer to speak with someone directly? Call us at (431) 430-5754 — we’re happy to help.

Integrity Painting — Winnipeg painters who never cut corners. We paint them.