.jpg)
Choosing the right paint is more than picking a color. The type of paint you use determines how long your finish lasts, how well it resists moisture, and how easy it is to maintain. The debate of acrylic latex vs oil based paint is one that every professional painter has weighed in on — and for good reason. Both have their strengths, but understanding where each shines can save you time, money, and future headaches.
At Integrity Painting, we’ve worked with both across countless commercial and residential projects throughout Winnipeg. Here’s a breakdown to help you make an informed choice before your next paint job.
Before we get into performance, let’s clarify what separates acrylic latex vs oil based paint on a chemical level.
Acrylic latex paint is water-based, made with acrylic resins that give it flexibility and durability. It dries fast, cleans up easily with soap and water, and releases fewer fumes — making it ideal for interiors and eco-conscious projects.
Oil-based paint, on the other hand, uses natural oils or synthetic alkyds as its base. It takes longer to dry, requires mineral spirits for cleanup, and produces a smoother, glossier finish that’s highly resistant to wear and tear.
In short: latex is easy to work with, oil is tough as nails.
.png)
When comparing acrylic latex vs oil based paint, durability is one of the most important factors. Oil-based paints form a hard shell once dry, which makes them extremely durable and great for trim, doors, and high-traffic areas. They resist scratches and dents but can become brittle over time, leading to cracking or yellowing.
Acrylic latex paints are more flexible. They expand and contract with the surface as temperatures change, preventing peeling and flaking. For Winnipeg’s climate — where hot summers and freezing winters test every surface — that flexibility is a major advantage.
Verdict: Oil wins on initial toughness, but acrylic latex holds up better long-term in changing weather conditions.
If you’re after that ultra-smooth, glass-like finish, oil-based paint still sets the gold standard. Its slow drying time allows brush strokes to level out perfectly. That’s why traditionalists and fine-finish contractors still swear by it for woodwork and cabinetry.
Acrylic latex paints have improved dramatically over the past decade. Modern formulas from Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore now deliver consistent coverage and smooth finishes that rival oil paints — without the fumes or long cure times.
Verdict: Oil-based paints win for ultra-smooth gloss; acrylic latex paints offer cleaner color and better fade resistance.
Here’s where acrylic latex vs oil based paint diverges sharply. Oil paints release higher levels of VOCs (volatile organic compounds), contributing to indoor air pollution and environmental harm. They also require solvents for cleanup, which can be hazardous if not handled properly.
Acrylic latex paints are low-VOC, water-based, and safer for both painters and occupants. For homeowners or businesses that want a sustainable, low-odor option — especially in occupied spaces — latex is the clear choice.
Verdict: Acrylic latex is the eco-friendly winner.
For busy homeowners or commercial property managers, time matters. Acrylic latex paints dry quickly — often within an hour — allowing for two-coat applications in the same day. Oil-based paints can take six to eight hours to dry, or even longer in humid conditions.
That speed makes latex ideal for interior jobs where downtime must be minimized. However, the longer drying window of oil-based paint gives professionals more time to correct brush marks and achieve that perfect sheen.
Verdict: Acrylic latex saves time; oil offers more working time.
.jpg)
In the conversation of acrylic latex vs oil based paint, maintenance often seals the deal. Once cured, oil paints are incredibly easy to clean and resist moisture well, which makes them ideal for trim or bathroom walls. But they can yellow over time, particularly in low-light rooms.
Acrylic latex paints stay true to color for years and resist fading from sunlight. Cleanup is simple — soap and water do the trick — and touch-ups blend seamlessly.
Verdict: Acrylic latex offers easier maintenance and better long-term color stability.
Budget often influences the final choice. Oil-based paints tend to cost more due to their ingredients and cleanup requirements. Acrylic latex paints are more affordable, easier to apply, and cover more square footage per gallon.
While oil paints may last slightly longer in high-impact areas, most property owners find latex paint delivers better overall value — especially when factoring in labor and drying time.
Verdict: Acrylic latex provides the best return on investment for most projects.
Still not sure when to use acrylic latex vs oil based paint? Here’s a quick guide:
Verdict: Choose acrylic latex for versatility and low maintenance. Opt for oil when a hard, polished finish is essential.
At Integrity Painting, we don’t just pick a paint — we plan a finish. Our Winnipeg team evaluates your surfaces, lighting, and environment before recommending the ideal paint type for your home or building. Whether it’s acrylic latex vs oil based paint, we’ll guide you toward a finish that lasts, looks exceptional, and fits your goals.
We partner with trusted brands like Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore to ensure every project reflects our commitment to quality and craftsmanship. From commercial interiors to residential repaints, our results stand the test of time.
Whether you're planning a full strata repaint, refreshing your living room walls, or upgrading your commercial space — we’re here to make your project stress-free and beautifully done. With over 30 years of experience in Winnipeg, our team is trusted by hundreds of homeowners and property managers across the city.
We paint with purpose, precision, and pride.
Visit our homepage or get started by exploring our:
Prefer to speak with someone directly? Call us at (431) 430-5754 — we’re happy to help.
Integrity Painting — Winnipeg painters who never cut corners. We paint them.